Table of contents

Get insights delivered straight into your inbox every week!

How to Set Up DKIM for Cold Emails

Q: What happens if I don't set up DKIM for my cold email campaigns?

Failing to implement DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) for your cold email campaigns can cause major headaches for your outreach and damage your brand's reputation. Without DKIM in place, your emails are more likely to end up flagged as spam or outright rejected by email providers, which can seriously hurt your deliverability rates. On top of that, the lack of DKIM leaves your domain open to spoofing and phishing attacks, putting your brand's credibility and trust on the line. Setting up proper email authentication like DKIM is a must. It not only ensures your emails land in your recipients' inboxes but also safeguards your domain and builds trust with your audience.

Q: How do I fix issues like DNS delays or syntax errors when setting up DKIM?

To address problems like DNS propagation delays or syntax errors during DKIM setup, start by using a reliable DNS lookup tool to verify that your DKIM record has been published and is accessible. Remember, DNS changes don’t take effect immediately - they can take up to 48 hours to propagate, depending on your DNS settings, particularly the TTL (Time to Live) value. If you encounter syntax errors, carefully review your DKIM TXT record for formatting issues. Common problems include using invalid characters, having multiple records for the same selector, or using RSA keys that are shorter than 1,024 bits. Proper formatting is critical to ensure your record validates correctly and supports your email deliverability. For those managing multiple domains or mailboxes, tools like Mailforge can streamline the DNS setup process. These platforms help automate configurations, reducing the risk of errors and making DKIM setup much smoother.

Q: What are the benefits of automating DKIM setup for large cold email campaigns, and how does Mailforge make it easier?

Automating DKIM setup is a game-changer for large-scale cold email campaigns . It not only saves valuable time but also cuts down on the hassle of manual configuration. Plus, it plays a key role in boosting email deliverability by ensuring proper authentication. This reduces the risk of your emails landing in spam folders and helps maintain a strong sender reputation. Tools like Mailforge make this process even easier. They automate the setup of DKIM , DMARC , and SPF records, streamlining the management of multiple domains. By ensuring compliance with email authentication standards, Mailforge allows businesses to expand their outreach efforts with confidence - without getting bogged down by the technical side of email security.

Manav Singh

June 5, 2025

•

5 min read

Setting up DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) is essential. DKIM ensures your emails are verified, trustworthy, and unaltered during delivery. Without it, your emails might get blocked or flagged as spam, especially since major providers like Google and Yahoo now require DKIM for bulk senders.

Key Takeaways:

What is DKIM? A digital signature that proves your emails are legitimate.
Why it matters: Boosts deliverability, protects against phishing, and builds sender trust.
How to set it up:
1. Generate keys (public/private).
2. Add the public key to your domain’s DNS as a TXT record.
3. Test your setup with tools like MXToolbox or by checking email headers.
Common issues: DNS delays, syntax errors, or mismatched key lengths.
Automation tools: Platforms like Mailforge simplify DKIM setup for large campaigns.

Why act now?

Starting February 2024, DKIM is mandatory for bulk emails. Set it up today to protect your sender reputation and ensure your emails make it to inboxes.

Before You Start: DKIM Setup Requirements

Getting DKIM set up properly starts with having the right tools and access in place. By preparing ahead of time, you can avoid unnecessary delays and complications.

Confirm Domain Ownership

Before diving into DKIM configuration, it's crucial to confirm that you own or control the sending domain. This step ensures that no one else can set up email authentication for domains they don’t have permission to use.

To verify ownership, log into your DNS control panel. If you can edit your domain's DNS records, that confirms your ownership.

The location where you manage your DNS records depends on your domain's nameservers. For example:

If your domain is registered with providers like GoDaddy or Namecheap and uses their nameservers, you'll manage DNS settings through their platform.
If your domain is registered with one company but uses another's nameservers (e.g., for hosting), you'll manage DNS records via the hosting or DNS provider, not the registrar.

To determine where your nameservers are pointing, check your domain registrar's control panel or use a WHOIS lookup tool. If you're unable to access DNS settings, reach out to your domain hosting provider for help.

Once ownership is verified, you can shift your attention to handling the DNS records required for DKIM.

DNS Records Basics

With access to your domain secured, it’s time to focus on DNS records, a key part of setting up DKIM. Specifically, you’ll work with TXT records, which store text-based data.

For DKIM, TXT records are used to publish your public key. This key allows receiving email servers to validate your messages. These records follow a specific naming format that includes a selector (a unique identifier you define) and your domain name. For example, a DKIM record might look like this: mailjet._domainkey.yourdomain.com.

If you're managing DNS through a cloud service like Google Cloud DNS, you'll need the proper permissions:

DNS Administrator (roles/dns.admin): For full read-write access.
DNS Reader (roles/dns.reader): For read-only access.

Permissions can be granted at the project level or for specific DNS zones. To maintain security, always follow the principle of least privilege - only grant the access users need to get their job done.

Familiarize yourself with the labels in your DNS management interface (e.g., "DNS Records") to navigate settings more efficiently. This knowledge will streamline the setup process.

How to Set Up DKIM: Step-by-Step Instructions

Setting up DKIM involves three main steps: generating the keys, adding the public key to your DNS records, and testing the configuration.

Generate Your DKIM Key Pair

DKIM relies on a public-private key pair. The private key is used to sign your outgoing emails, while the public key is added to your domain's DNS records so receiving servers can verify those signatures.

Microsoft 365 Users: For custom domains, Microsoft handles key generation for you. When you enable DKIM in the admin center, the system creates two CNAME records that point to Microsoft's managed keys. No manual key generation is required.
Google Workspace Users: Go to the Admin Console, then navigate to Apps > Google Workspace > Gmail > Authenticate Email. Choose your domain and click "Start authentication." Google will generate the keys and provide the DNS records you need to add.
Custom Setups or Other Platforms: You can generate keys manually using tools like PUTTYGen on Windows or the ssh-keygen command on Linux and macOS. Opt for 2048-bit encryption for stronger security, though 1024-bit keys are still functional. You'll also need to choose a selector name, such as "default", "s1", or a date-based identifier like "2025may." The selector helps identify where the public key is stored in your DNS.

Once your keys are created, store them securely. The private key will be used for signing emails, and the public key will be added to your DNS. Make sure to save your selector name - it’s essential for setting up the DNS record.

Add the Public Key to DNS

After generating the keys, the next step is to publish the public key in your domain's DNS by creating a TXT record.

The DNS record name follows this format: [selector]._domainkey.[yourdomain.com]

For example, if your selector is "s135" and your domain is example.com, the record name will be: s135._domainkey.example.com

Here’s how to set it up:

Access your DNS management system.
Create a new TXT record with the name [selector]._domainkey.[yourdomain.com].
Add the public key as the value, starting with v=DKIM1;. A sample record might look like this:
```
v=DKIM1; k=rsa; p=MIGfMA0GCSqGSIb3DQEBAQUAA4GNADCBiQKBgQC...
```
For Microsoft 365 Custom Domains: Instead of a TXT record, you’ll create two CNAME records. For example, if your domain is cohovineyard.com, the records might look like this:
- Hostname: selector1._domainkey
  Points to: selector1-cohovineyard-com._domainkey.cohovineyardandwinery.n-v1.dkim.mail.microsoft
- Hostname: selector2._domainkey
  Points to: selector2-cohovineyard-com._domainkey.cohovineyardandwinery.n-v1.dkim.mail.microsoft

Once the records are added, allow time for DNS propagation before testing the setup.

Test Your DKIM Setup

Testing ensures your DKIM configuration is working as intended. Here’s how to verify it:

Send Test Emails: Send emails to Gmail or Yahoo accounts and inspect the message headers. In Gmail, look for "signed-by: yourdomain.com" in the email details. In Yahoo Mail, check for "dkim=pass" in the headers.
Manually Inspect Email Headers: Check for the "DKIM-Signature" header and confirm that the "Authentication-Results" indicate a pass.
Use Online DKIM Checker Tools: Tools like MXToolbox or EasyDMARC can validate your DNS records and ensure your public key is configured correctly. As EasyDMARC explains:

"Our DKIM checker tool simplifies the DKIM record-checking process by locating your domain's DKIM record and validating its accuracy." – EasyDMARC
For Microsoft 365 Users: Use the built-in testing feature in the admin center to confirm that outbound emails are signed correctly. Note that DKIM signatures may not appear for emails sent within the same domain or organization.
Monitor DMARC Aggregate Reports: Regularly review DMARC reports to ensure your email authentication protocols are functioning properly.

Getting DKIM right can improve email deliverability by reducing spam scores. This is especially important as Google and Yahoo have announced that, starting February 2024, bulk email senders must use DKIM and SPF authentication, along with a DMARC policy set to "p=none".

If your tests reveal issues, common culprits include DNS propagation delays, syntax errors in your records, or mismatched key lengths. These problems can usually be resolved with a few adjustments.

Fixing Common DKIM Setup Problems

When setting up DKIM, it’s not uncommon to run into a few hiccups. Issues like DNS propagation delays, syntax errors in records, and key length mismatches can disrupt your email authentication. Here’s how to address these common problems.

DNS Propagation Delays

DNS propagation can take anywhere from 30 minutes to 48 hours for DKIM records to be fully updated worldwide. For example, a tech startup once faced failures because they began signing emails with a new key before propagation was complete.

To avoid this, wait at least 24–48 hours after updating your DKIM records before using the new key for signing. If you want to speed things up, try lowering the TTL (Time To Live) value for your DNS records temporarily. You can also use online DNS propagation tools to check how your changes are progressing globally. If local updates still aren’t showing, flushing your DNS cache might help.

DKIM Record Syntax Errors

Even after propagation, syntax errors in your DKIM record can cause validation failures. For instance, a university generated a new DKIM key but mistakenly entered the wrong selector in its DNS record. This error prevented email validation until the correct selector was added.

Here are some common syntax mistakes to watch out for:

Missing version tag: Always start your DKIM record with v=DKIM1;.
Incorrect selector format: The DNS record name should be [selector]._domainkey.[yourdomain.com].
Malformed public key: Ensure the public key is a single continuous string without any line breaks or extra spaces.
Missing semicolons: Separate each parameter in the DKIM record with a semicolon.

Use DNS lookup tools to confirm that your DKIM record is correctly published and that the selector matches exactly between your email server and DNS record.

Key Length Issues

Key length mismatches can also cause validation problems, especially when dealing with older systems or certain DNS providers. For example, one company experienced failures when their DNS still held a 1024-bit public key, while their email system had switched to a 2048-bit private key.

Although 2048-bit keys are more secure, some DNS providers have character limits for TXT records. If this happens, you can split the public key into smaller chunks within the same TXT record using concatenation. Check with your DNS provider to confirm their key length support. If necessary, you can temporarily switch to a 1024-bit key, as suggested by Google, though most modern providers like Cloudflare handle 2048-bit keys without issues. For providers with limitations, contacting their support team can help identify specific workarounds.

To stay ahead of these issues, enable DMARC reporting. Regularly review DKIM failure reports to catch patterns early and prevent email deliverability problems.

sbb-itb-fe3169b

Automating DKIM for Large-Scale Cold Email Campaigns

Once your DKIM records are properly configured, the next hurdle is managing them efficiently at scale. When dealing with a large number of domains, manual management quickly becomes impractical. Automation can drastically reduce setup times - from hours to mere minutes - making it an essential tool for scaling cold email campaigns.

Let’s break it down: If you're sending 10,000 emails per month, you’ll need 12 domains and 36 mailboxes (3 per domain). This setup enables you to send 1,080 new prospect emails daily. However, each domain requires its own DKIM configuration, which means 12 separate DNS setups if done manually. Automating this process not only simplifies your workflow but also integrates seamlessly with your broader email authentication strategy.

Using Mailforge to Simplify DKIM Setup

Mailforge

Mailforge turns what used to be a painstaking, multi-hour task into a fast and efficient process. By automating DNS record creation, Mailforge eliminates the need for manual edits. Once you determine your sending capacity using Mailforge's domain calculator, the platform can automatically generate the necessary domains through its dashboard. From there, it takes care of all the DNS configurations - including generating DKIM keys and placing records - saving you hours of work.

"Procedures that usually took hours (setting DKIM, SPF, etc. records) for multiple domains, now take a few minutes. Mailforge is also cost-efficient since you spend per mailbox ~3 times less than with Gmail."

Karlo Binda, Founder Leadsnack.co

Mailforge also supports bulk DNS updates, allowing you to modify multiple domain configurations at once. This feature is especially helpful when rotating DKIM keys or updating authentication settings across a large portfolio of domains.

Benefits of Automated DKIM Management

Automation isn’t just about saving time - it also reduces costs and lowers risks. Emails without proper authentication are three times more likely to end up in spam folders. On top of that, 68% of organizations misconfigure their DMARC policies, which can seriously harm email deliverability. Automated DKIM management can cut first-year costs by 40–60% compared to manual setups and ongoing maintenance. Here’s a quick cost comparison:

Factor	Manual Setup Cost	Automated Cost
Initial Setup	$2,000–$5,000 (IT labor)	$500–$2,000 (one-time fee)
Maintenance Costs	$1,200–$3,000 (IT/security team hours)	$50–$300 (managed service plans)
Risk of Non-Compliance	High (manual errors)	Low (automated enforcement)
Threat Response Time	24–72 hours	<1 hour (AI monitoring)

Beyond the financial benefits, automation offers proactive threat detection and real-time monitoring. With 45% of global email traffic classified as spam and email lists degrading by 22.5% annually, keeping your email authentication in check is critical. Automated systems can detect and resolve authentication failures in under an hour, compared to the 24–72 hours it typically takes with manual monitoring. This not only protects your sender reputation but also ensures your campaigns remain effective.

The scalability of automated DKIM management is undeniable. By 2025, 85% of enterprises are expected to adopt DMARC.

"Nowadays, target buyers' inboxes have become more competitive than ever... ISPs have become far more selective about what emails get inbox placement or go to spam... I strongly believe if you don't have a product to monitor and improve inbox placement... your reps messaging isn't being seen by even your most targeted personas."

Richard Mullins, Head of Global Business Development at Workvivo

Automating DKIM management not only ensures consistent security across all your domains but also strengthens trust with email providers. When combined with SPF and DMARC protocols, it creates a robust defense for your domains.

Conclusion

DKIM plays a crucial role in verifying your sender identity and improving email deliverability. By implementing DKIM, you're essentially adding an encrypted "seal of approval" to your emails, which helps build trust with both email providers and recipients.

Key Points to Keep in Mind

Think of DKIM as your email's digital signature - it ensures that every message you send is verifiable and untampered. As mentioned earlier, statistics highlight how DKIM can protect against email attacks and spoofing. When combined with SPF and DMARC, DKIM strengthens your email's reputation and security.

Setting up DKIM isn't instant - DNS propagation may take up to 48 hours - but the payoff is worth it, as it enhances email deliverability. For stronger security, opt for 2048-bit encryption keys, and ensure your DKIM signatures align with your "From" addresses to maximize trust.

Next Steps to Take

Now that you understand DKIM's benefits, it's time to take action. Start by implementing DKIM on your primary domains as outlined earlier. Regularly monitor your authentication reports to spot and resolve any issues promptly. Also, rotating your DKIM keys periodically helps maintain a high level of security.

To simplify the process, consider automating your DKIM management. Tools like Mailforge can handle DNS configurations and bulk updates, ensuring your email infrastructure stays strong as your operations expand. By automating this, you ensure consistent security while scaling your email efforts. Start implementing DKIM today to tackle deliverability challenges and secure your email infrastructure for the future.

FAQs

What happens if I don't set up DKIM for my cold email campaigns?

Failing to implement DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail) for your cold email campaigns can cause major headaches for your outreach and damage your brand's reputation.

Without DKIM in place, your emails are more likely to end up flagged as spam or outright rejected by email providers, which can seriously hurt your deliverability rates. On top of that, the lack of DKIM leaves your domain open to spoofing and phishing attacks, putting your brand's credibility and trust on the line.

Setting up proper email authentication like DKIM is a must. It not only ensures your emails land in your recipients' inboxes but also safeguards your domain and builds trust with your audience.

How do I fix issues like DNS delays or syntax errors when setting up DKIM?

To address problems like DNS propagation delays or syntax errors during DKIM setup, start by using a reliable DNS lookup tool to verify that your DKIM record has been published and is accessible. Remember, DNS changes don’t take effect immediately - they can take up to 48 hours to propagate, depending on your DNS settings, particularly the TTL (Time to Live) value.

If you encounter syntax errors, carefully review your DKIM TXT record for formatting issues. Common problems include using invalid characters, having multiple records for the same selector, or using RSA keys that are shorter than 1,024 bits. Proper formatting is critical to ensure your record validates correctly and supports your email deliverability.

For those managing multiple domains or mailboxes, tools like Mailforge can streamline the DNS setup process. These platforms help automate configurations, reducing the risk of errors and making DKIM setup much smoother.

What are the benefits of automating DKIM setup for large cold email campaigns, and how does Mailforge make it easier?

Automating DKIM setup is a game-changer for large-scale cold email campaigns. It not only saves valuable time but also cuts down on the hassle of manual configuration. Plus, it plays a key role in boosting email deliverability by ensuring proper authentication. This reduces the risk of your emails landing in spam folders and helps maintain a strong sender reputation.

Tools like Mailforge make this process even easier. They automate the setup of DKIM, DMARC, and SPF records, streamlining the management of multiple domains. By ensuring compliance with email authentication standards, Mailforge allows businesses to expand their outreach efforts with confidence - without getting bogged down by the technical side of email security.